By: Tom DeRoche​

In a recent conversation, AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka suggested that the American labor movement, second only to the military, has provided the majority of skills training and adult education in the United States and with positive results.

Those who work with Apprenti​ceship and Training Programs​ know that their graduates have lower rates of absence, better safety records and higher industry/employer loyalty. I frequently hear from our members that graduates of apprenticeship programs also tend to experience lower unemployment, lower debt and similar lifetime earnings to college graduates.


The success of these programs is rooted in an experiential learning model that combines hands-on learning, support through mentoring, and on-the-job training. Yet, apprenticeship progra​ms still struggle​. In part, this is because our secondary educational model is not generally set up to be a feeder to these successful programs.

[Related: Benefit Bits Video—Dr. Robert B. Schwartz, Ph.D. on Youth Apprenticeships]

As the economy has struggled in recent years, many college graduates have found themselves either unemployed or underemployed. For at least some of these graduates, exposure to alternative paths might have yielded a different outcome.

Several initiatives could expand apprenticeship programs and ultimately produce a more employable skilled labor force:

  • Implement career planning and exploration into our school systems at a young age
  • Recognize that not every child should be college-bound
  • Level the playing field so that college prep is not the only supported path in high school
  • Improve instructor training at all levels
  • Integrate technology tools to enhance learning
  • Encourage partnerships between schools and businesses to incorporate real-life learning experiences. 

I am not, in any way, suggesting that there is no value to a traditional college degree. I happen to have one that has afforded me many opportunities. What I am saying is that the world has changed and our educational focus needs to meet the demands of the workforce.

Tom DeRoche

Director of Educational Programs at the International Foundation


Favorite Foundation service/product: Face to face conferences

Favorite Foundation conference/event moment:  The US Annual Conference…so many members, so many friends, gathered by their commitment to education, to their participants and the benefits industry.  It’s hard not to be inspired.

Benefits related topic that interests him most: Retirement Security


Recommended Posts

Best Practices for Multiemployer Retirement Plan Death Audits

Jenny Gartman, CEBS

Fiduciaries have many responsibilities that stem from the duties of care, loyalty and prudence, including ensuring the correct benefits are paid to the correct participants and beneficiaries of the plan. Benefits Magazine authors Lisa L. Kaiser, CEBS, and Carey R. Wooton, CEBS, explain […]