The Department of Labor’s (DOL) Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) new guidance recommends that health plan fiduciaries consider mental health parity compliance when selecting and monitoring service providers. The guidance appears aimed at common misunderstandings around service provider support, including assumptions that service providers will prepare MHPAEA comparative analyses, or that their processes are already compliant. EBSA provided sample questions for selecting health plan service providers, with extra help for plans with carve-out arrangements. EBSA also provided detailed steps for monitoring how medical necessity and network adequacy are applied in practice to mental health benefits and physical health benefits.
Who Are Health Plan Service Providers?
Health plan service providers can include third-party administrators (TPAs), managed behavioral health organizations, claims administrators, consultants and network administrators.
Laws and Acronyms Refresher
The Paul Wellstone and Pete Domenici Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) requires group health plans that provide mental health and substance use disorder (MH/SUD) benefits to cover those benefits in parity with medical/surgical (M/S) benefits. The 2021 Consolidated Appropriations Act added the requirement for plan sponsors to conduct a comparative analysis of nonquantitative treatment limitations (NQTLs), which has been challenging for many plans, according to annual EBSA enforcement reports.
What Are Carve-Out Arrangements?
DOL uses the term carve-out arrangements for situations where MH/SUD benefits are purchased or managed separately from M/S benefits. A plan has a carve-out arrangement when it uses a different administrator or different network for MH/SUD benefits than for M/S benefits.
Common Challenges With Different Service Providers
According to the 2025 MHPAEA Report to Congress, concerns with noncompliant comparative analyses arose especially often when plans had different service providers handling MH/SUD and M/S benefits and those service providers were not communicating with each other or aware of the processes or standards used by the other.
For instance, EBSA enforced a final determination of noncompliance on a self-funded health plan’s NQTL comparative analyses. The plan had carve-out arrangements with different claims processors. The plan’s comparative analyses contained information generated separately by its M/S claims processor and its MH/SUD claims processor, which were unrelated entities. Each claims processor identified factors used in the design of NQTLs for M/S claims that differed from those used in the design of NQTLs for MH/SUD claims. The comparative analyses from one claims processor did not compare or contrast the factors, strategies, evidentiary standards and processes described by the other claims processor.
EBSA investigators requested that the plan reconcile the different information it had collected from its service providers. In other words, it was the self-funded plan’s responsibility to use the information it collected from the two service providers to create comparative analyses that compared how NQTLs were applied to MH/SUD benefits and M/S benefits.
Common Misunderstandings About Service Provider Support
Some self-funded plans have been confused about their MHPAEA compliance responsibilities. For example, EBSA reported that some plan sponsors mistakenly believed that a service provider’s claims review processes or template coverage products were compliant with MHPAEA, or they mistakenly assumed their service provider had a comparative analysis or would prepare one for them.
According to EBSA investigators, plans with carve-outs rarely obtained a complete comparative analysis from either service provider. Some service providers refused to provide a comparative analysis or were unable to give the information needed for a plan to assess its own MHPAEA compliance.
Plans with carve-out arrangements should closely review the information provided by their service providers to ensure there is a meaningful comparison of each service provider’s information.
Fiduciary Duties for Selecting and Monitoring Service Providers
Self-funded plans are responsible for MHPAEA compliance. Health plan fiduciaries must prudently select and monitor plan service providers and are responsible for ensuring that the benefits those providers administer comply with MHPAEA.
Sample Questions for Service Providers About MHPAEA Compliance
According to EBSA informal guidance, plan fiduciaries should ask existing and prospective health plan service providers the following types of MHPAEA-focused questions:
- What MH/SUD benefits are offered, and what limitations apply to these services?
- How often do you review your processes and procedures for developing your network and benefits for MHPAEA compliance?
- What do you do to review for MHPAEA compliance?
- Will you share with me any MHPAEA-specific compliance reports or compliance analyses applicable to this plan or coverage?
- Do you assist with evaluating MHPAEA compliance, including preparing a comparative analysis for each NQTL that is specific to my plan?
- What if my coverage is self-funded? What if I customize my MH/SUD benefit options?
- What if my coverage is fully insured?
- What compliance assistance will you provide if my plan uses a different administrator or different network for MH/SUD benefits than for M/S benefits? These are often called carve-out arrangements where MH/SUD benefits are purchased or managed separately from M/S benefits.
- Will you provide me with periodic reports so I can monitor trends in MH/SUD claims, including out-of-network utilization for my plan? If so, will such reports be customized to my plan?
- Upon request, will I have access to underlying data relating to MHPAEA compliance?
- What assistance will be provided if my plan is the subject of a state or federal mental health parity investigation?
- Are your assistance and such reports included in my contract without an additional fee?
- Do you cover telehealth MH/SUD services?
- Are there differences between how MH/SUD claims are administered and how M/S claims are administered?
- Are there any timing differences or additional administrative burdens applied to MH/SUD claims that differ from those applicable to M/S claims prior to approval?
- What providers are available in-network for both MH/SUD and M/S? What specialties and subspecialties are available in-network for both MH/SUD and M/S?
- How do you ensure a robust MH/SUD network?
- What steps are taken to recruit and keep providers in the network? How do those steps differ, if at all, between MH/SUD providers and M/S providers?
- What assistance is available to plan participants who are unable to find an available and appropriate in-network MH/SUD provider? How does that assistance vary as compared with M/S providers?
- Do you use access goals and metrics to evaluate the adequacy of the network? If so, what are the goals and metrics? Are the access goals and metrics different for MH/SUD care as compared to M/S care? Have you found that there is parity in network adequacy between MH/SUD and M/S networks?
- Do you have a process for receiving and documenting participant complaints? What is that process? How does that process differ, if at all, between complaints related to MH/SUD benefits vs. M/S benefits? What are your most common reasons for complaints?
RFP Updates
Plan fiduciaries can use EBSA’s sample questions to update future RFPs and review whether existing service provider contracts align with the responses received. Retaining this documentation can help show prudent selection. It remains unclear whether DOL will provide future guidance on how plans should evaluate service providers’ answers.
Best Practices for Monitoring Operational Compliance
DOL provided detailed steps for checking whether two NQTLs, medical necessity and network adequacy, are permissible. Generally, medical necessity and network adequacy NQTLs can be impermissible if the processes, strategies or evidentiary standards used to apply themto MH/SUD benefits are not comparable to, or are applied more stringently than the processes, strategies or evidentiary standards used to apply the NQTLs to M/S benefits.
Steps for monitoring operational compliance to ensure that NQTLs applicable to MH/SUD services satisfy parity requirements as compared to M/S services include the following.
Medical Necessity Standards and Review Process
- Check the list of benefits subject to the NQTL(s) for both MH/SUD and M/S benefits; flag significant disparities in scope of applicability.
- Understand why and how benefits are added or removed from the list. If standards are used to make such decisions, compare standards applied to MH/SUD benefits vs. M/S benefits.
- Review prior authorization and concurrent review (PA/CR) claims submission process, considering the burden on participants and providers, such as the kinds of documents required as part of the review; the required frequency of review; length of time for each approval; and use of automated vs. manual review, including use of peer reviews or subject matter experts in the claim review process.
- Track and respond to participant complaints, and train staff on handling complaints, including available resources to address complaints.
- Compare penalties for failure to get PA/CR for MH/SUD and M/S benefits.
- Periodically review datapoints related to how PA/CR and retrospective review are applied in practice and trends over time. Consider tracking claim volume and denial rates separately by benefit type and provider type, as well as monitoring turnaround time for review.
- Review plan documents and participant disclosures for inaccurate information.
Provider Network Adequacy Processes
- Inquire and assess how your network administrator evaluates the adequacy of the network to meet the plan’s coverage needs and ensure timely access to care. Identify any applicable standards, how they are assessed and whether they are met. Ask about what is done when any standard is not met.
- If your plan allows out-of-network (OON) exceptions for participants who cannot find a network provider, review those policies and the data relating to their implementation, checking for disparities between MH/SUD and M/S benefits.
- If special efforts are made to address network gaps for M/S services, understand whether and why such efforts are made to address network gaps for MH/SUD services.
- Monitor OON utilization of M/S services as compared to MH/SUD services. Track trends over time. Consider comparing percentages of overall claim volume, claim value and participant volume by benefit type and provider type.
- Track and respond to participant complaints, and train staff on handling complaints, including available resources to address complaints.
- Review processes for providers to join the network and related summary data. Consider comparing M/S vs. MH/SUD percentages of applications approved versus denied, applications withdrawn, and average time to approve or deny the application.
- Assess patient wait times, any applicable standards, how they are assessed and whether they are met, and note any differences between M/S and MH/SUD services.
Monitoring Operations
For medical necessity and network adequacy NQTLs, create and follow a written monitoring policy or incorporate these steps into existing policies. If monitoring shows access problems, disparities or other red flags, take corrective action and document it. Documentation can help show prudent monitoring of plan service providers.
Regulatory Developments to Watch
For December 2026, the regulatory agenda shows a “deregulatory” proposed rule that would “clarify plans’ and issuers’ obligations, promote compliance and reduce burden.”
Developed by International Foundation Information Center staff. This does not constitute legal advice. Please consult your plan professionals for legal advice.


