Pros and Cons of Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs)

A flexible spending account (FSA) is an individual account that can reimburse an employee for qualified medical expenses and work-related dependent care expenses.

Is offering an FSA plan worthwhile? Let’s look at some of the pros and cons for both employers and employees, as explained in the new International Foundation Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs) elearning course.

Pros and Cons of Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs)

Pros and Cons for an Employer

Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs) E-Learning Course

Pros:

An employer may favor offering an FSA for the following advantages:

  • FSAs give employers flexibility in designing the plans as long as they are compliant with federal laws and regulations regarding contributions, reimbursements, claims substantiation and other administration issues.
  • Health care FSAs (HCFSAs) provide a reduction in employer payroll taxes.

Cons:

However, an employer takes on the following risks when offering an FSA plan:

  • Under the uniform coverage rules, the employer is required to reimburse expenses that occur during the coverage period up to the participant’s annual election amount without regard to the participant’s account balance. If a participant terminates employment or loses eligibility, the employer cannot recoup those funds reimbursed in excess of the amount that the employee deposited to date.
  • FSAs may require more employer administration than HSAs and HRAs.

Comparing FSAs, HSAs and HRAs [Watch Now]

FSA Pros and Cons for an Employee

Pros:

From an employee perspective, one of the biggest advantages of participating in an FSA is the tax-free nature of the account.

  • Employee and employer contributions are not included in an employee’s gross income and qualified expenses are paid or reimbursed on a tax-free basis.
  • Aside from substantiating claims as they are incurred, a participant is not required to file any additional forms at tax time (except Form 2441 for dependent care FSA participants).
  • HCFSAs can be offered in conjunction with any type of employer-sponsored group health plan, whereas HSA participation is strictly limited to those who are enrolled in a qualified high deductible health plan (HDHP) and no other disqualifying coverage.

Cons:

The following aspects of flexible spending accounts may be less favorable from the employee perspective:

  • Because FSA design and plan options vary from employer to employer, an employee needs to learn about the features of their particular FSA plan to understand how to use it correctly.
  • HCFSAs have the lowest annual contribution limits compared to HRAs and HSAs.
  • Compared to HSAs and HRAs, employers are least likely to contribute to an HCFSA.
  • FSAs are subject to the use-it-or-lose-it rule unless the employer adopts a grace period or carryover provision when available. This means employees must be especially thoughtful and anticipate future medical expenses when setting annual elections.
Preparing Your Organization for the Next Crisis

Many factors should be weighed before implementing an FSA plan. The International Foundation offers helpful e-learning courses that provide a deeper dive into FSA, HSA and HRA plans. Tap into these courses to learn about plan design, compliance requirements, tax advantages, reimbursement rules, claims substantiation and other administration considerations.


Ann Godsell, CEBS
Director, Professional Development Marketing at the International Foundation

The latest from Word on Benefits:

Staff

Director, Professional Development Marketing at the International Foundation

Favorite Foundation Product: Face to face conferences. Benefit Topics That Grab Her: Benefit communication, preventive health, health care cost management, workflex Favorite Foundation Conference Moments: Meeting Dr. Andrew Weil at the Annual Employee Benefits Conference was a cherished opportunity. She also loves the times when she and a member recognized each other at a conference because of interacting on Twitter! Personal Insight: Known around the office as “appropriately paranoid,” Ann is usually prepared for a variety of potential outcomes in most every situation.

Recommended Posts

Open pharmacy pill containers on a pile of 20 dollar bills.

What the Executive Order Increasing PBM Fee Transparency Means for Employers

Amanda Wilke, CEBS
 

On April 15, 2025, President Trump signed the executive order (EO) “Lowering Drug Prices by Once Again Putting Americans First,” which includes specific actions to be taken by federal agencies to reduce prescription drug costs, improve transparency and increase competition in the […]

GLP-1 Drug Coverage Continues to Rise in Canada 

Rebecca Plier
 

New Survey Data Reveals Prior Authorization or Other Utilization Management Strategies, Eligibility Requirements, Annual Maximum as Leading Cost Control Methods  A new survey report from the International Foundation of Employee Benefit Plans reveals updated Canadian employer coverage and cost-control mechanisms surrounding glucagon-like […]

GLP-1 Drugs Responsible for Over Ten Percent of Annual Claims 

Rebecca Plier
 

New Survey Data Reveals Rise of GLP-1 Drug Claims, With Utilization Management and Eligibility Requirements as Leading Cost-Control Mechanisms   A new survey report from the International Foundation of Employee Benefit Plans reveals updated U.S. employer coverage and claims representation surrounding glucagon-like peptide-1 […]